19/11/2026
THURSDAY | NOV 19, 2026
5
Former excos withdraw constitutional suit
Woman alleges beatings, forced strip in custody
PETALING JAYA: The wife of a former Eastern Sabah Security Command (ESSCOM) officer has told the Tawau High Court that police forced her to undress and beat her while she was in remand. She gave her account as a plaintiff in a RM190 million civil suit brought by former ESSCOM officers and personnel. Vivien Fabian, 38, the wife of a former ESSCOM officer and the sole civilian plaintiff in the lawsuit, became emotional while recounting her alleged ordeal from the witness stand. Her testimony also included claims that police used her children to pressure her into confessing to involvement in the murder of e-hailing driver Nurman Bakaratu three years ago. Vivien alleged that her children were brought to the Tawau District Police Headquarters and made visible to her through a one-way mirror while she was being questioned. She claimed the incident took place in the presence of two police officers, a woman and a man. She also said the female officer subsequently instructed her to remove her clothes. She added that she had initially been pressured to confess and taken to a palm oil plantation where the murder had occurred, but refused because she was not involved in the killing. “Throughout my remand, I was threatened and coerced; the police used my children against me, allowing me to see them through a one-way mirror. I knew they had brought my children there specifically to exert pressure on me. “I was then taken to meet my husband (John Kennedy Anak Sanggah) in an interrogation room. “I saw a white sheet of paper lying on the table; they wanted me to memorise what was written on it. “I refused to follow their instructions because I knew the paper claimed that I, along with the other individuals (the plaintiffs), were present at the scene where Nurman Bakaratu was killed. “I removed my clothes, one by one, until I was completely naked, and I was ordered to squat while facing the wall.” Vivien was responding to further questions from her lawyer, Datuk Ram Singh, during examination-in-chief about her allegation that she had been forced to undress while in police custody. She added that she complied because she was frightened and did not know what might happen if she refused. She added that she could not establish whether the male officer remained in the room at the time, as she had been instructed to face the wall. Vivien further alleged that the male officer covered her eyes with a face mask before
repeatedly slapping her around the ears with both hands. She claimed the female officer then instructed her to turn towards the door before striking her back between 10 and 15 times. When asked why she had not lodged a police report immediately, Vivien said she was afraid and did not know she had the right to make a complaint while in remand. She said she eventually filed a report while being held at Tawau Prison, after receiving advice from a lawyer who had recently taken over her representation. During cross-examination by Senior Federal Counsel (SFC) Mardziatun Nisa Ahamadul Kaber, Vivien rejected the suggestion that police had not used physical or psychological pressure to force her to implicate others. Referring to her witness statement, she maintained that she had been slapped, kicked and struck on the back and chest, as well as forced to remove her clothes by the investigating officer. However, Vivien acknowledged that she had not raised the alleged assault or mistreatment with the magistrate when brought before the court on Jan 29, 2023. She also agreed that she had not been referred for a medical examination at a hospital on that date or during another court appearance on Feb 4, 2023. Nevertheless, she rejected Mardziatun’s assertion that the police officers named as defendants had never used her children to intimidate or psychologically torment her. She also denied suggestions that her allegations of assault, mistreatment, forced stripping and the use of her children as a means of pressure had been fabricated or exaggerated to strengthen her civil claim. She further maintained her position on the damages sought, rejecting the suggestion that her claims were without basis. These include RM20 million in general damages, RM10 million in exemplary damages, special damages and a demand for a public apology. Judicial Commissioner Steve Ritikos subsequently discharged Vivien, the 14th witness, after her testimony concluded. In January 2023, Vivien, former ESSCOM Chief of Intelligence Staff SAC Datuk Mat Zaki Md Zain and six of his personnel had been detained in January 2023 over their alleged involvement in the murder of e-hailing driver Nurman. However, on Jan 25, 2024, they were granted a discharge and acquittal (DAA) by Judge Datuk Duncan Sikodol after the prosecution withdrew the charges following key witness Nurima Juli’s admission of guilt in connection with the murder. – by theSun team
o Move follows recent resignation by Negeri Sembilan MB: Lawyer
fixed timelines for preliminary objections. She added that parties who seek urgent relief on constitutional questions about a state government must be mindful that judicial resources are held in trust for the public. The state secretary’s counsel, Datuk Dr Cyrus Das, and the state government’s counsel, Razlan Hadri Zulkifli, consented to the withdrawal on the agreed terms. The counsel for the DKU, Steven Thiru, took the same position. The former Exco members had asked the court to interpret the State Constitution. They named the state secretary and the state government as defendants, and DKU was allowed to intervene. Hafarizam appeared with Tan Sri Azhar Azizan Harun, Datuk Syed Faisal Al-Edros Syed Abdullah, Norhazira Abu Haiyan and Muhammad Luqman Hakeem Abas for the plaintiffs. The state secretary was also represented by Abdul Rashid Ismail, Siti Nurani Md Zahidi and Diong Pei Jing. Razlan Hadri was joined by Marisa Regina Mohd Aris Rizal and Muhammad Yazid Mohamad Salim for the state government. The DKU team comprised Steven Thiru, David Mathew, Shafrin Halim and Gurjeevan Singh.
the case. He also said under the state constitution the resignation of a menteri besar brings down the entire Exco with him. Roz Mawar noted that Ismail had not formally left office at the time of the hearing. She added that he had submitted a resignation letter, but the consent of Yang di-Pertuan Besar, Tuanku Muhriz Tuanku Munawir, had not been received. Hafarizam replied that the plaintiffs had first sought an adjournment to Friday, giving Tuanku Muhriz time to decide on the resignation. He said after speaking to their clients, they chose to withdraw instead. The court ordered the plaintiffs to pay RM20,000 in costs to the state secretary, RM20,000 to the state government and RM8,000 to the Dewan Keadilan dan Undang (DKU). The amounts are subject to allocatur fees. Roz Mawar said the court does not discourage litigants from discontinuing proceedings and that doing so could be the wiser course. However, she noted that the court had spent a great deal of time and resources on the case. She said the summons was filed under a certificate of urgency, and the court dealt with several applications and
Ű BY THESUN TEAM newdesk@thesundaily.com
PETALING JAYA: Ten former Negeri Sembilan state executive councillors have dropped their court challenge over the constitutional crisis in the state. They did so without the right to raise the matter again. The Seremban High Court was told yesterday that the group was discontinuing its originating summons against the state secretary and two other parties. Judge Roz Mawar Rozain approved the withdrawal after their lawyer, Datuk Mohd Hafarizam Harun, said it covered the whole case, including an application invoking the Federal Court’s original jurisdiction. He also confirmed that the plaintiffs would not refile, even by way of judicial review. Hafarizam said the move followed recent developments over Menteri Besar Datuk Ismail Lasim’s resignation. He added that the position of his clients was that events had overtaken
SERENE SCENERY ... A visitor admires a koi pond within The Rainforest nature attraction at the 1Utama shopping centre in Selangor. – AMIRUL SYAFIQ/THESUN
Chinese nationals nabbed over suspected scam KOTA KINABALU: The Sabah
Sitti Saleha said an examination of one of the computers accessible to the authorities uncovered financial transaction records involving several countries, including India and Cambodia, with individual transactions ranging from US$950 to US$1,500. She added that the premises were believed to have been used to carry out scam activities targeting victims both locally and abroad. She urged the public to continue providing information to the authorities on the presence of suspicious foreign nationals to assist efforts to curb immigration-related criminal activities in Sabah. – Bernama
10 initially refused to produce their travel documents. However, following persuasion, four of them eventually presented their passports, and checks revealed that they had overstayed,” she told a press conference yesterday. She added that the operation also led to the seizure of 153 mobile phones of various models, 11 computers, a central processing unit (CPU), a printer, 13 Internet routers, seven chargers, 22 SIM cards and three passports issued by China. She also said various foreign currencies, including those from Cambodia, Vietnam, China, Thailand and Malaysia, were seized.
Immigration Department detained 12 Chinese nationals suspected of being involved in online scam activities during a raid in Taman Perumahan Damai. Sabah Immigration Director Datuk Sh Sitti Saleha Habib Yussof said the men, aged between 20 and 43, were detained at 11am on Tuesday on suspicion of committing offences under the Immigration Act 1959/63. “Investigations found that four of them had overstayed and misused their immigration passes, while the remaining eight failed to produce valid travel documents. “Of the 12 individuals detained,
Made with FlippingBook - Online magazine maker